Logan Physio Logo Dark

Navigating the Nuances of Foot Pain: Plantar Fasciitis vs. Plantar Fascia Tear

Turning fifty is a milestone that many approach with mixed feelings, and for Sandy, a seasoned physiotherapist from Logan Physio, it was a moment to celebrate life, vitality, and family, little did he know he would be facing a stark reminder of his own vulnerability. A friendly soccer game with his daughters and friends quickly turned into a personal case study of foot pain, as he experienced a sharp tearing sensation in his heel—a moment that would lead him down the path of distinguishing between plantar fasciopathy and a plantar fascia tear.

The Initial Encounter: A Jolt of Pain

Soccer is a sport known for its sudden bursts of speed and agility, and during the game, Sandy experienced a pain that was abrupt and terrifying: a sharp, tearing sensation underneath her heel.The intense pain that gripped Sandy’s heel while stepping forward to chase down the ball was the kind that could freeze any athlete in their tracks. His thoughts immediately went to a diagnosis of Achilles tendon rupture, however he soon realized the culprit was located elsewhere. This precision in understanding the exact origin of pain and its behavior is crucial for anyone experiencing similar symptoms. An accurate assessment is the first step toward appropriate treatment.

Plantar Fasciitis: A Chronic Overuse Injury

Sandy had been experiencing pain in his heel prior to the incident, which is indicative of plantar fasciopathy. This condition results from chronic overuse, leading to degeneration of the plantar fascia—usually presenting as a dull, persistent pain that develops gradually over time. Here, the collagen fibres of the plantar fascia undergo microtears and degeneration due to overuse and stress. As a physiotherapist, Sandy knew he suffered this condition prior to this incident and was managing it accordingly. Plantar fasciitis is associated with an overload on the plantar fascia often due to excessive running, changes in training loads, improper footwear, or even an aberrant foot structure.

Plantar Fascia Tear: An Acute Traumatic Event

Contrastingly, the acute, intense pain that emitted from Sandy’s heel on the soccer field is characteristic of a plantar fascia tear—a more sudden and traumatic injury. The diagnostic journey, which involved an X-ray to clear bony involvement such as a fracture, and a conclusive ultrasound, revealed a tear measuring nine millimeters. A plantar fascia tear is not as common as fasciopathy and usually follows a significant, forceful impact or excessive strain.

The Differential Approach in Recovery

Sandy’s approach to recovery offers insight into handling each condition. For plantar fasciopathy, treatment may involve rest, stretching, proper footwear, and gradual strengthening exercises to rehabilitate the degenerated tissue. However, when confronted with a tear, as in Sandy’s case, the strategy shifts to immediate immobilization in a moon boot, weight-bearing as tolerated, and the use of walking aides such as crutches if needed. Before he got the moonboot Sandy had his foot taped to unload the damaged tissue. Sandy approached his treatment with the caution of a professional. Aware of the research surrounding certain anti-inflammatory medications, he opted for minimal doses of Neurofen. Ice application was sparse, only twice, adhering to the latest findings on injury management, which suggest as inflammation is part of the natural healing process we need not limit it excessively. 

Through this personal episode, Sandy’s experience may become a beacon for others dealing with plantar fascia injuries—teaching us that with the right measures and mindset, one can navigate the path to recovery and return to the joys of an active life, even when it starts with an unexpected setback.

Book Your Appointment With A Health Care Professional